A California appellate court explained why TruConnect’s foreseeable financial losses did not by themselves establish a negligence duty against government software contractors.
Businesses often depend on software supplied under a contract between a vendor and someone else. When that system fails, serious and predictable financial harm may follow. But those facts alone do not answer the threshold question: did the vendor owe the affected business a duty of care?
What Happened in TruConnect
In TruConnect Communications, Inc. v. Maximus Inc., No. A172474 (Cal. Ct. App. Nov. 19, 2026), the First Appellate District, Division One, reviewed claims against Maximus Inc. and Solix Inc., which the California Public Utilities Commission had hired to design and implement a LifeLine enrollment platform. The official Judicial Branch listing identifies the November 19 filing and its partial-publication status. 1 2
According to TruConnect’s operative complaint, platform defects improperly rejected eligible applicants and renewing subscribers, causing more than $20 million in lost revenue. TruConnect also alleged that its personnel spent hundreds of thousands of hours addressing the problems, at a cost exceeding $3 million in time and resources. These were complaint allegations accepted for demurrer review—not trial findings or an award. 1
The appellate court affirmed dismissal after the trial court sustained a demurrer without leave to amend. A demurrer challenges whether a complaint states a legally sufficient claim; it is not a trial weighing the evidence. The court concluded that the pleaded circumstances did not establish the negligence duty TruConnect needed. 1
Purely Economic Loss Is Different
Purely economic loss means financial loss that does not arise from actionable personal injury or physical property damage. Economic damages can also follow actionable physical harm; lost income in that setting is not the same kind of standalone financial injury. Southern California Gas Leak Cases (2019) 7 Cal.5th 391, 398–401, explains California’s general restriction on negligence recovery for purely economic losses and the recognized special-relationship exception. 3
This is not a rule that all lost revenue is unrecoverable. Nor does the absence of a direct contract automatically defeat every negligence claim. The claim’s legal theory, the nature of the injury, the parties’ relationship, and applicable exceptions all matter.
The Special-Relationship Analysis
Biakanja v. Irving (1958) 49 Cal.2d 647, 650, identifies policy considerations for assessing duty without contractual privity: 4
- The transaction’s intended effect on the plaintiff.
- Foreseeability of harm and certainty of injury.
- The closeness of the connection between conduct and injury.
- Moral blame attached to the conduct.
- The policy of preventing future harm.
These considerations are weighed together; they are not a mechanical checklist that guarantees recovery. In TruConnect, the court accepted that errors were foreseeably harmful and that the alleged defects could be connected to the claimed losses. But it found the government contract’s purpose was not necessarily to benefit TruConnect and weighed concerns about liability disproportionate to fault and a sophisticated business’s ability to seek contractual or insurance protection. 1 3
The court also explained that this tort-duty inquiry is not identical to contractual third-party-beneficiary enforcement. Failing one test does not automatically answer the other, although related policy concerns may inform both. 1
What the Ruling Does Not Decide
The result turns on the pleaded relationships and claims. It does not give software vendors blanket immunity or eliminate other claims that may arise from different conduct, agreements, or injuries.
TruConnect’s negligent-interference claim failed because it depended on the rejected negligence duty. Its unfair-competition claim also failed as presented because it was derivative of that claim; the court did not hold that every UCL claim requires negligence. 1
The opinion is certified for partial publication, excluding parts II.B and II.C. Those unpublished sections are not used here as precedent for general restitution or necessary-party rules. 1 2
Planning Takeaway: Allocate the Risk Before Reliance
Before relying on a third-party platform, evaluate who owes enforceable obligations, what service commitments exist, and how the agreements allocate losses. Relevant considerations may include:
- Direct contractual protections and service-level commitments.
- Indemnification, liability limitations, and exceptions to those limits.
- Applicable insurance and its actual terms, exclusions, and limits.
These are matters to evaluate, not guarantees of compensation or findings that particular coverage was available to TruConnect. A business should also separate gross lost revenue from net lost profits and identify any overlap with remediation expenses; the alleged figures should not be totaled as though they were an adjudicated award. Mahrouyan Law’s Business Litigation and Startup & Business Transactions practices address different aspects of commercial disputes and technology-related agreements.
Sources
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- 4.
Discuss Your Matter
If your business relies on technology or services supplied under another party’s contract, contact Mahrouyan Law to discuss your circumstances and whether the firm can assist.

Omeed Mahrouyan is the founder of Mahrouyan Law, P.C., a California firm handling business and commercial litigation, property and cargo damage claims, personal injury, landlord representation, startup transactions, and practical intellectual property matters. Clients work directly with him on strategy, drafting, and case decisions.
More about Omeed Mahrouyan →
