A reported $8.15 million settlement in Peck v. County of Orange shows why an appellate ruling, an entered damages judgment, and a negotiated settlement must be described separately.
City News Service reported on November 17, 2026 that Orange County reached an $8.15 million settlement with Susan Peck, the widow of Paul Mono, a legally blind Laguna Woods resident who was fatally shot by Orange County sheriff’s deputies in 2018. According to that report, the case settled while the county’s appeal to the Ninth Circuit was pending (City News Service report). 3
That reporting is the source for the settlement announcement. We have not independently reviewed an executed settlement agreement, payment, allocation, or appellate dismissal.
What the Court Actually Awarded
The federal case is Susan Peck et al. v. County of Orange et al., No. 2:19-cv-04654, in the Central District of California. After a jury trial, the court entered an amended judgment on November 21, 2025 (amended judgment, Dkt. 346). 1 It provided that:
Susan Peck, as representative of Paul Mono’s estate, recover $5,648,000 from the County of Orange on the estate’s Americans with Disabilities Act claim; and Peck, individually, recover $105,600 from five deputies, jointly and severally, on her negligence claim. The $105,600 is one collective award, not $105,600 per deputy. 1
Together, those amounts total $5,753,600 in principal. The judgment dismissed the plaintiff’s other claims with prejudice, separately provided for postjudgment interest, and retained jurisdiction to consider postjudgment motions, including a motion for fees and costs. 1 News descriptions of a “$6 million verdict” round that figure; the entered judgment controls the details.
Why the Legal Theories Differ
The ADA claim was brought on behalf of the estate against the county and concerned the county’s disability-related statutory obligations. The negligence claim was a separate state-law tort theory, brought by Peck individually, and produced a separate award against the identified deputies. 1
The constitutional excessive-force claim involved a different inquiry. In Peck v. Montoya (9th Cir. Oct. 18, 2022) 51 F.4th 877, the Ninth Circuit heard an interlocutory appeal from the denial of summary judgment based on qualified immunity (Ninth Circuit opinion). 2 Viewing the facts in the light most favorable to the plaintiff, as the summary-judgment framework requires, the court affirmed the denial of qualified immunity to the two deputies who fired “at this stage of the litigation.” It reversed as to the three deputies who did not shoot, and held that all of the deputies were entitled to qualified immunity on the Fourteenth Amendment familial-association claim. [2]
That ruling allowed the excessive-force claim against the two shooting deputies to proceed; it did not establish their ultimate liability at trial. The judgment later entered was based on the ADA and negligence claims, not an excessive-force damages award, even though some news coverage uses that shorthand. 1 Qualified immunity is a defense the court addressed for the constitutional claims against individual deputies; the opinion did not decide the ADA or negligence claims. 2
Judgment Versus Settlement
The $5,753,600 amended judgment and the reported $8.15 million settlement are different things. A judgment is the court’s entered determination of what a party may recover on the claims tried. A settlement is a negotiated agreement between the parties.
In general, accruing interest, potential fees and costs, the risk and expense of an appeal, and the value of finality can all affect settlement negotiations. The available materials, however, do not establish the precise allocation of this settlement or the reasons the parties agreed to this amount.
It would therefore be inaccurate to describe the full settlement as additional compensation, as Peck’s net recovery, as punitive damages, or as an admission of additional wrongdoing.
Practical Takeaway
Understanding a civil recovery requires identifying which claim succeeded, which defendant is liable, the procedural stage, and the terms of the actual judgment or agreement. A headline amount alone can obscure those distinctions.
For broader context on how injury claims are evaluated, see Personal Injury and How Much Is My Personal Injury Case Worth in California?
Sources
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
Discuss Your Matter
If you have questions about an injury claim, a judgment, or a proposed settlement, contact Mahrouyan Law to discuss your situation and whether the firm can assist.

Omeed Mahrouyan is the founder of Mahrouyan Law, P.C., a California firm handling business and commercial litigation, property and cargo damage claims, personal injury, landlord representation, startup transactions, and practical intellectual property matters. Clients work directly with him on strategy, drafting, and case decisions.
More about Omeed Mahrouyan →
