The Supreme Court returned Casarez for reconsideration under Montgomery. The order concerns federal preemption; it does not establish negligence or decide every claim against shippers and receivers.
A new Supreme Court order requires another look at a California truck-crash case involving claims against a produce grower and retailer. The immediate issue is how federal transportation law affects those claims—not whether either defendant has already been found responsible for the collision.
The order’s procedural posture matters. Reconsideration under a new precedent can change the legal analysis, but it does not supply the evidence needed to prove negligence or resolve every participant’s liability.
What the November 16 Action Did
In Casarez v. Irigoyen Farms, Inc., U.S. Supreme Court No. 25-1421, the Court’s November 16, 2026 order granted certiorari, vacated the appellate judgment, and remanded the case to California’s Fifth District Court of Appeal for further consideration in light of Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC, 608 U.S. 219 (2026). 1
In plain English, “vacated and remanded” means the appellate judgment was set aside and returned for reconsideration. The Supreme Court did not find either defendant negligent. Its order is not a damages award or an order sending the case straight to trial. The Court’s public docket likewise records the November 16 disposition; that is the last confirmed procedural development relied on here. 2
The Collision and Vacated California Decision
The 2025 opinion described a fatal September 27, 2019 collision involving a tractor-trailer transporting produce from Irigoyen Farms to a Walmart distribution center. Christina Casarez alleged independent negligence by the grower and retailer. As the opinion summarized her position, she alleged that Irigoyen Farms sent the driver onward despite contemporaneous knowledge of exhaustion and a long trip with only hours for delivery, and that Walmart’s contractual requirements encouraged reckless conduct by motor carriers. Those were allegations about the defendants’ own conduct, not established liability. 3
The earlier Fifth District decision affirmed summary judgment for Irigoyen Farms and Walmart on FAAAA-preemption grounds. Its judgment was subsequently vacated by the Supreme Court. The earlier preemption conclusion therefore appears here only as procedural history, not an undisturbed statement of current law. 1 3
Federal Preemption and the Safety Exception
The Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (FAAAA), 49 U.S.C. § 14501(c)(1), restricts certain state laws related to a transportation provider’s price, route, or service with respect to transportation of property. The provision addresses motor carriers and specified other transportation businesses; its application to particular claims and defendants requires legal analysis. 5
Section 14501(c)(2)(A) separately preserves state safety regulatory authority “with respect to motor vehicles.” Federal law therefore does not preempt every trucking-related claim. But calling a claim “safety-related” does not automatically resolve the exception’s scope or the claim’s connection to motor vehicles. 4 5
What Montgomery Decided—and Left Open
Montgomery held that the particular negligent-hiring claim against the freight broker fell within the FAAAA’s motor-vehicle-safety exception. The claim concerned the broker’s selection of a motor carrier and driver. The Court assumed without deciding that § 14501(c)(1) would otherwise preempt that claim, then concluded that the safety exception preserved it. 4
Casarez involves different alleged conduct by a grower and retailer, rather than the broker’s carrier-selection conduct in Montgomery. Montgomery arose in the broker context, but the Supreme Court’s Casarez order did not itself resolve how Montgomery’s reasoning applies to these particular claims against the grower and retailer. 1 3 4
Preemption Is Separate from Proving Negligence
Overcoming a preemption defense does not establish duty, breach, causation, or damages under state law. Those issues require their own legal and factual analysis. Participation in the same shipment does not automatically make every business liable.
- Shipper: tenders goods for transportation.
- Broker: arranges transportation.
- Motor carrier: provides transportation.
- Receiver: receives the shipment.
These are functional descriptions, not automatic liability rules. Actual conduct, contractual undertakings, control, knowledge, and legal relationships matter.
Why Transportation Records Matter
Contracts, communications, carrier-selection records, loading observations, and delivery instructions may help establish what each participant actually did. They may also reveal whether disputed requirements existed and how they related to the trip. No single document necessarily resolves negligence or causation.
This discussion concerns collision-related negligence and wrongful death. It does not automatically determine claims for damaged cargo, trailers, or equipment, which may involve different statutes and legal theories. Mahrouyan Law’s Personal Injury and Business Litigation practices address different aspects of serious collisions and commercial disputes.
Sources
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- 4.
- 5.
Discuss Your Matter
If a truck collision raises questions about a transportation participant’s role, contact Mahrouyan Law to discuss your circumstances and whether the firm can assist.

Omeed Mahrouyan is the founder of Mahrouyan Law, P.C., a California firm handling business and commercial litigation, property and cargo damage claims, personal injury, landlord representation, startup transactions, and practical intellectual property matters. Clients work directly with him on strategy, drafting, and case decisions.
More about Omeed Mahrouyan →
