Skip to content
Personal Injury

North Hollywood Crash Charges: How Criminal Prosecution and California Wrongful-Death Law Differ

By Omeed Mahrouyan · Published November 15, 2026
Separate criminal proceeding and civil liability folders beside a bronze balance, illustrating distinct legal questions under California law.

Charges announced after a fatal North Hollywood collision illustrate how California separates criminal prosecution, wrongful-death compensation, restitution, and punitive damages.

On November 13, 2026, the Los Angeles County District Attorney announced charges following a November 10 collision near the North Hollywood Metro station that killed three women and seriously injured two others. Prosecutors allege the driver was impaired. 1

Criminal charges are accusations. They are not a conviction, and they are not a determination of civil liability.

What Prosecutors Announced

According to the District Attorney, Ihor Demianenko faces three felony murder counts and two felony alcohol-related driving counts causing injury in Case No. 26VWCF02111. Prosecutors allege his blood alcohol concentration was more than three times the 0.08% legal limit. 1

The announcement stated that arraignment was scheduled for November 16, 2026. This article does not report whether the arraignment has occurred or whether a plea has been entered. 1

As the District Attorney’s announcement notes, the charges are allegations, and the accused is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty. This article does not address any civil lawsuit; none has been confirmed. 1

Why Criminal Prosecution and Civil Liability Are Different

Prosecutors bring criminal charges on behalf of the state. Civil claims are brought by eligible people seeking compensation for legally recognized harm.

The standards of proof also differ. In a criminal case, the state must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. 8 In a civil case, unless the law provides otherwise, the burden of proof is a preponderance of the evidence, which generally governs ordinary negligence claims. 9

Filing charges does not prove negligence, and a civil negligence claim generally does not require a criminal conviction to succeed. That does not mean criminal proceedings never matter in a civil case; whether a plea, verdict, or testimony has evidentiary or preclusive effect requires separate analysis.

Who Can Bring a Wrongful-Death Claim, and What It Compensates

California gives the right to bring a wrongful-death claim to specified people, not automatically to every relative or person affected by a death. Eligible claimants include a surviving spouse or registered domestic partner, children, and, if there is no surviving issue, those who would inherit by intestate succession. Certain dependent family members and qualifying dependent minors in the household may also be eligible. A personal representative may assert the claim on their behalf. 3

The court may award damages that are just under the circumstances, but not damages recoverable in the deceased person’s own survival action. 4 Depending on proof and applicable law, recoverable losses can include financial support the decedent would have contributed, gifts or benefits, funeral and burial expenses, the reasonable value of household services, and the loss of the decedent’s love, companionship, comfort, care, and moral support. 5

These losses are not compensation for grief or sorrow as such. A wrongful-death claim compensates survivors’ own losses, while a survival action pursues claims the deceased person held before death. For more on that distinction, see our Insight on California survival actions.

When Punitive Damages Can Be Available

Punitive damages generally are unavailable in an ordinary California wrongful-death action. Civil Code § 3294(d) creates an exception: punitive damages may be recovered in a wrongful-death action based upon a death that resulted from a homicide for which the defendant has been convicted of a felony. 2

The exception is not limited to murder convictions, but it requires a felony conviction for the homicide itself. A murder charge, a DUI allegation, or an unrelated felony conviction does not by itself satisfy that condition. 2

Even with a qualifying conviction, an award is not automatic. Section 3294 still requires clear and convincing evidence of oppression, fraud, or malice, each of which the statute defines. 2

This conviction requirement concerns wrongful-death punitive damages. Punitive-damages claims in a survival action, or claims brought by people who were injured and survived, are distinct and require separate analysis.

How Restitution Differs From Civil Damages

If a defendant is convicted, Penal Code § 1202.4 generally requires the court to order restitution directly to victims for economic losses resulting from the defendant’s conduct. The court must also impose a separate restitution fine, which is paid to the state rather than to victims, unless it finds compelling and extraordinary reasons not to. 6 7

Restitution is not the same as full civil damages, and an order does not guarantee payment. It focuses on economic loss, while civil damages can include other categories of loss. 6

Restitution payments, civil recoveries, insurance benefits, and reimbursement rights must be coordinated under the applicable rules. For example, the statute provides that the restitution amount is not affected by a third party’s indemnification or subrogation rights, and that restitution is deposited in the Restitution Fund to the extent a victim received state victim-compensation assistance. 6

The Takeaway

A criminal case asks whether the state can prove a crime. A wrongful-death claim asks whether eligible survivors can prove compensable losses. Restitution addresses economic loss within a criminal case, and punitive damages in a wrongful-death action depend on a felony conviction for the homicide and the additional requirements of § 3294. Each question is decided under its own rules.

Mahrouyan Law’s Personal Injury practice addresses California injury and wrongful-death questions.

Sources

  1. 1.
  2. 2.
  3. 3.
  4. 4.
  5. 5.
  6. 6.
  7. 7.
  8. 8.
  9. 9.

Discuss Your Matter

If you have questions about a California injury or wrongful-death matter, contact Mahrouyan Law to discuss it. Every situation depends on its own facts and applicable law.

Omeed Mahrouyan, founder of Mahrouyan Law, P.C.
Omeed Mahrouyan
Founder & Principal Attorney
Mahrouyan Law, P.C.
California Bar No. 352171 · State Bar profile

Omeed Mahrouyan is the founder of Mahrouyan Law, P.C., a California firm handling business and commercial litigation, property and cargo damage claims, personal injury, landlord representation, startup transactions, and practical intellectual property matters. Clients work directly with him on strategy, drafting, and case decisions.

More about Omeed Mahrouyan →